Siyapath
Sign up

Lesson: Chapter 2 — Photosynthesis

Is light needed? 2 of 3

One leaf covered

Take away the light from one part of one leaf, leave everything else exactly as it was, and see what the iodine says.

You need

A potted plant that has been kept in the dark for 48 hours, the materials for the starch test, and strips of black and of colourless polythene.

Method

  • From the potted plant that has been kept in the dark for 48 hours, choose two leaves of equal size — call them leaf A and leaf B. Cover part of leaf A with black polythene, and part of leaf B with colourless polythene.
  • Then leave this arrangement for 3 to 5 hours in a place where sunlight falls on it.
  • Carry out the starch test on leaves A and B as described in activity 2.2.

Figure to be added

Figure 2.5 — a plant in a clay pot. One leaf, labelled A, has a black polythene square clipped over part of it; another leaf, labelled B, has a colourless polythene square over part of it in the same way.

Why leaf B is covered too

It would have been simpler to cover one leaf and leave the other bare. It would also have been a worse experiment. Covering both means the two leaves differ in exactly one thing — whether light reaches them — and are alike in everything else, including being wrapped in plastic. Leaf B is the control.

Without the control, an objection is available

Suppose only leaf A were covered, and it produced no starch. Someone could reasonably say the polythene had stopped the air getting to it, or trapped heat, or damaged it. Leaf B answers all of those at once: it has polythene on it too, and it behaved differently. The only thing left that could explain the difference is the light.